The City of Fort Collins in Colorado is known among tourists and residents for its scenery, cultural attractions, and environmental focus, and among municipalities for its sense of organizational direction and performance management. Fort Collins believes the best performance reviews address metrics and also encourage conversations about performance and actionable steps toward improvement. It hasn't always been easy to review performance the way the city does today.
The City of Fort Collins is in Colorado, against the Rocky Mountain foothills alongside the Cache la Poudre River, about 5,000 feet above sea level. It has about 170,000 residents (2023), who live in about 73,000 housing units. Fort Collins is a home rule city with a Council/Manager government. It is also home to Colorado State University. The city publishes a Community Dashboard, a public, quarterly snapshot of the community's progress toward its key outcomes.
When Fort Collins started tracking performance, it focused entirely on metrics, organized like a pyramid in three segments. At the top were 38 metrics showing progress toward 7 defined strategic Outcomes (for example, "Safe Community" and "Economic Health"). The second layer was a larger group of metrics tracked to support budget requests and show how council funding contributed to performance. At the bottom was a broad range of foundational metrics for daily operations rather than strategy.
The first performance review meetings discussed the top layer - the metrics on Fort Collins' Community Dashboard - with the executive team and all department heads. It quickly became clear that a meeting this large was costly and did not hold everyone's interest, since so many metrics fell outside each attendee's department and focus.
The strategy implementation team changed the meetings to focus separately on individual Service Areas, which are groups of related departments at the city. Each Service Area Director and their department heads would meet quarterly with the City Manager, Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer in what were named Quarterly Service Area Reviews (QSAR). All metrics contributing to budget requests would be reviewed too, since data could be sent out in advance. Fort Collins used ClearPoint reports as pre-reading to show charts, data, evaluations and analysis. This was an improvement, but the budget metrics brought the total to more than 400, and it was not possible to review so many metrics in the time allotted.
To reduce the amount to review, department heads were asked to pick the 3-5 most important metrics they tracked. That narrowed meetings to less than 200 'primary' metrics. Discussions improved, but there still wasn't enough context about why these metrics mattered, so more adjustments were needed to show the broader picture.
In addition to the QSARs, Budget Director Lawrence Pollack pushed for a more strategic executive review focused on the city's performance in achieving its biennial strategic plan. This time Fort Collins shifted attention from the metrics themselves to the Outcomes it was striving to achieve. For each key Outcome, the strategic plan had 5 to 9 strategic objectives, reviewed through the 3 to 4 metrics linked to each. The programs and services (aka initiatives) linked to those objectives and funded in the budget were reviewed as another lens on performance. This gave more context around funding and budgeting: what programs and services was the city providing with the funding allocated? How did the performance of these initiatives translate to achieving the strategic objectives?
They call these reviews Strategy Maps, with MAP standing for Metrics, Analysis and Performance. Different Outcomes are reviewed each month in a series of 40 to 50-minute meetings so that all Outcomes are covered each quarter. Two ClearPoint reports - one for metrics and one for initiatives - are sent out as pre-reading and used as the basis for each discussion. Pollack reports that "standardization of the material is key, as far as having people be able to read and review all the content in these reports." There isn't time in the reviews to discuss every metric and initiative tied to each strategic objective, so materials are read ahead. The meeting can then celebrate successes and spend its time on the action plans to get underperforming metrics and initiatives back on track.
Because they knew how much work had gone into crafting the review process, Pollack's team put communication, documentation and training plans in place alongside the Strategy Maps. The structure helps make these reviews, and the use of ClearPoint, effective.
They also wanted the process to work for everyone, so Pollack's team scheduled quick, individual meetings with department heads to explain the process and make sure their needs were met. They built a review calendar showing timelines for each Outcome's review, deadlines for data entry, and when pre-reading would be sent. The team periodically checked in more broadly on what was working and what was not. Pollack made sure departments knew they weren't locked into a process. "If you have a way to improve it," he said, "then we'll make those changes real-time throughout the year." Department Heads can also modify existing metrics to improve their usefulness and even replace them with more meaningful ones.
How do these reviews and Strategy Maps align with a leadership system that puts heavy emphasis on Mission, Vision, and Values? At the top of the new pyramid are the key outcomes - the high-level goals that drive Fort Collins' vision. Supporting them are conversations about the objectives and how to measure progress toward them. Then come the commitments to the community through the budget - the programs and services designed to achieve the strategic objectives. ClearPoint's reporting let the city use the tool it already had for metrics as it expanded this approach.
As a result of these reviews, Fort Collins no longer sees initiative statuses slipping as the year goes on. Continuous review keeps progress steady, so departments are not over-extended and nothing gets forgotten. Feedback from across the organization indicates departments are connecting reviewing progress to improving life for the Fort Collins community. They've learned there's no one-size-fits-all approach and continuous improvement is key. Pollack's advice to others looking to improve their review process? Just get started!