A CIP is easy to write and hard to keep. Here is what the cities that finish their capital plans do right, from named owners to year-two habits.
Key Takeaways
  • Put a person's name on every capital project. Projects with a named owner are completed more than twice as often as those with none.
  • Update a project's status when the field work finishes. ClearPoint shows which projects past their deadline are still open in the plan of record.
  • Review every active project monthly or quarterly. A short check catches the slip early; plans die when nobody opens them between adoptions.
  • Publish the CIP on a public dashboard. Owners update what residents can see; Hayward publishes its whole program live.
  • Track your projects in the free capital project tracker. It runs in the browser with no account, and gives the plan one shared view.
Google AI answers

Get our answers first in Google.

Add ClearPoint as a preferred source →

Somewhere in a city budget office, there is a binder. Five years of capital projects. A road widening, a fire station, a water main that was supposed to be replaced in 2019. Every number in it is real. Every project was approved. And a lot of them will still read “in progress” when the next five-year plan is written.

This is the part of capital planning that never makes it into the guide. So we pulled the data. We looked at 3,131 capital projects across 100 local governments to see where the plan actually breaks, and what the cities that finish their plans do differently.

First, the definition, because you probably came here for it.

If you’d rather build it than download a file, use the free capital project tracker. It works in the browser with no account, and asks for email only if you want to export.

What a capital improvement plan is — and what it isn’t

A capital improvement plan (CIP) is a multi-year schedule of a local government’s major physical investments. Think roads, bridges, buildings, water and sewer systems, parks, fleet. For each project, the plan lists the estimated cost, the operating and maintenance cost that follows, a timeline, and where the money comes from. Most CIPs span five to ten years. Five is the most common.

A CIP is not the same thing as a capital budget. The capital budget is one fiscal year of funding. The CIP is the runway. The first year rolls into this year’s budget, and the rest sets the schedule for what comes next. The Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) draws the line at assets above a set capitalization threshold, often $5,000, with a useful life beyond a single year. Below that line, it’s an operating expense, not a capital project.

So far, so textbook. You can find that definition on a dozen government finance sites, and they are all roughly correct. Here is what they leave out.

The uncomfortable part: funded, then forgotten

A CIP is easy to write and hard to keep. The plan gets adopted with real momentum: a council vote, a press release, a fresh spreadsheet. Then the fiscal year turns. A project manager leaves. A grant slips. And the plan quietly stops matching reality.

Some capital projects really are stalled. Others were finished in the field and simply never updated in the plan. The pavement got laid, but the record still says “in progress.” Both are the same failure wearing different clothes. When the plan stops telling the truth, no one can steer by it. The council asks how the CIP is going, and the honest answer is a shrug.

A CIP doesn’t fail in the strategy. It fails on a Tuesday, six months after adoption, when the plan and the worksite stop agreeing.

Finished projects have owners

When we split the same projects by whether a specific person is named as the owner, the gap is not subtle. Projects with a named owner get completed more than twice as often as projects owned by “the department,” which is to say, no one.

The owner effect

Share of capital projects completed, by ownership

Named owner19.7%
No owner9.0%
2.2×
A capital project with a named owner is completed more than twice as often. ClearPoint shows which capital projects still need an owner.

Source: ClearPoint platform data · 3,131 capital projects across 100 local governments · 2026

This is the least glamorous finding in capital planning, and the most useful. It’s the same pattern we see across government project performance as a whole: ownership is what moves work to done. You do not need a new software category to close most of this gap. You need a name next to each project, a person rather than a division, and a standing habit of asking that person how it’s going. Ownership is what turns a line item into an accountable commitment, and it is the throughline of local-government strategy execution: a plan only moves when someone owns each piece of it.

Which capital projects need the most attention

The pattern holds across every kind of capital work, but not evenly. The projects that fare worst are the ones that don’t fit a clean category: the “other” capital items that tend to be vaguely scoped and, tellingly, the least likely to have an owner.

Projects with the weakest definition and the weakest ownership need the most attention. Scope it, name it, and it has a chance.

What it looks like when it works

Some cities have already closed this gap, and they didn’t do it quietly. They did it in public, on public-facing dashboards any resident can open.

The City of Hayward, California publishes its entire Capital Improvement Program as a live dashboard. Ten categories, from road and street projects to pavement rehabilitation, municipal facilities, fleet, water, sewer, and airport work. Each project carries a number, a status, and a percent-complete. You can watch “Annual Water Line Replacements FY24” sit at 10% while a traffic control tower renovation reads 100%. Hayward’s 2024–2033 capital program runs to roughly $905 million, and none of it hides in a binder. When a project owner knows the whole city can see the number, the number tends to get updated.

The City of Goldsboro, North Carolina ran the same idea on the inside. Its CIP was a ten-year projection totaling $411 million in planned fund usage, and department heads logged in to rank their own projects by priority. Each one was tagged to its funding source (general, utility, stormwater), so a project read as progress toward a goal rather than a line of spend. Octavius Murphy, Assistant to the City Manager, put the culture plainly: “The city manager really likes data. He’s an analytical guy… so that support system is major for my desk.”

Two cities, one public and one internal, make the same move. The plan is a living system that names owners and shows status, not a document that gets admired once and shelved.

How to build a CIP that survives year two

You already know how to write a CIP. The components are settled: a project list, cost and O&M estimates, timelines, funding sources, and a way to rank what comes first. Assemble those and you have a plan. Here is how to keep it alive after the vote.

1. Put a name on every project: a person, not a department. This is the move that more than doubles completion. “Public Works” cannot be called into a meeting. A person can.

2. Give it one shared view. When the plan lives in one place everyone can see, instead of five spreadsheets and an email thread, status stops being a mystery and starts being a habit.

If that shared view means choosing software, the options split into two layers: the construction platforms that build each project and the reporting layer that rolls the program up to council. We compared both in capital project management software for local government.

3. Review on a cadence, not a crisis. A short monthly or quarterly check on every active project catches the slip while it’s still a slip. The plans that die are the ones nobody opens between adoptions.

4. Roll each project up to the goal it serves. A water main isn’t just $2 million of pipe. It’s the “safe, reliable infrastructure” objective in your strategic plan, made concrete. Connect the two and capital spend reads as strategic progress the council can follow.

5. Consider making it public. A resident-facing dashboard is not a vanity project. It’s the strongest accountability mechanism a city has, because owners update what the public can see. Hayward proves the point every day.

That last mile (owners, status, one live view of every capital project) is what ClearPoint was built to run. If you want to see it on your own plan rather than read about it, ask for a walkthrough.

See how ClearPoint would run your plan — book a demo

Sources & methodology

The completion and ownership figures in this article come from ClearPoint’s own platform data: an anonymized analysis of 3,131 capital-project initiatives across 100 municipal and county governments, current to 2026. Percentages describe that cohort; no single client is identified. The $5,000 capitalization threshold and the multi-year framing follow GFOA guidance. The public-dashboard example is the City of Hayward’s live CIP dashboard; the internal-CIP example and the Octavius Murphy quote come from the City of Goldsboro case study.

Common questions

How many years should a CIP cover?

Most local governments use a five-year horizon, though ten years is common for long-lived assets like water systems and major facilities. The exact length matters less than the annual review — a CIP that isn’t refreshed each year drifts out of date within a budget cycle.

Why do so many capital improvement plans fail to get finished?

They stall in execution, not in project selection. Across roads, water, and facilities, ClearPoint shows which past-due projects are still open in the plan. Some are truly stuck; others were finished in the field but never updated. The common thread is ownership: initiatives with a named owner complete at 2.5× the rate (21.5% vs. 8.7%).

Who should own a capital project?

A specific, named person, not a department or a title held by whoever is available. Putting a name on every project is the move that more than doubles completion in our data. The owner doesn’t have to swing the hammer; they have to be accountable for the status and answer for the slip.

Should a capital improvement plan be public?

It helps more than most cities expect. A public, project-level dashboard — like the City of Hayward’s — turns transparency into an execution tool, because owners keep the numbers current when residents and council can see them. It also answers the “where did our money go” question before anyone has to ask it.

Ted Jackson
Ted Jackson
Co-Founder & Alabama Native

Co-Founder and Managing Partner of ClearPoint. Former VP at Kaplan and Norton's Balanced Scorecard Collaborative.

Ted Jackson is the co-founder of ClearPoint Strategy, a B2B SaaS platform that empowers organizations to execute strategic plans with precision. Before ClearPoint, he was Vice President at the Balanced Scorecard Collaborative — later the Palladium Group — the firm Drs. Robert Kaplan and David Norton founded to put their framework into practice, where he led global sales and support for its strategy management software and wrote three articles for the Balanced Scorecard Report. A Duke and Harvard Business School alumnus, he brings over 30 years' experience in strategy execution, including 15 years implementing the Balanced Scorecard in the field. Ted works closely with customers to ensure the software meets unique challenges, continually refining the platform with his global expertise.