From Data Entry to Value Add

Arapahoe County, Colorado is home to over 650,000 residents south of Denver. The county has over 2,300 full-time employees across 17 offices and is governed by a five-member board of city commissioners that serves as its policymaking body. Because an elected board, rather than a single administrator, governs the county, these officials are heavily involved in county management.

Laura Mazur, one-half of the team of two in the Strategy and Performance Department, talks with Ted Jackson, ClearPoint Strategy co-founder, about facilitating the county’s performance management program.

Watch the full conversation here!

About Arapahoe County

Arapahoe County is in Colorado, with its county seat in Littleton. Denver was the original seat until 1902, when Arapahoe County was divided into five counties. The county spans approximately 805 square miles and acts through a Board of County Commissioners. Its population is 651,215, and only Denver and El Paso counties are larger. The county publishes a public County Scorecard to track progress and keep residents informed. County offices are at 5334 S. Prince St., Littleton. Its official site is arapahoeco.gov.

Data, Data, Data

When Arapahoe County launched its Performance Management Program, the goal was to collect as much data as possible. The county wasn’t tracking data in any wide-scale way, and the data that was tracked wasn’t kept together. It was difficult for employees to know where data was and what it meant. The program has evolved since then, particularly since the COVID-19 pandemic.

“Before, they were just inputting data to input it.”

The data wasn’t helping departments make short- or long-term operational decisions or be strategic about resource allocation. Now the county has been able to evaluate what data is useful and how to expand those measures, and what is not and should be archived.

In ClearPoint, Arapahoe County organizes scorecards into County, Department, and Division levels. The county scorecard houses 20 “Index Measures,” which include contributions from multiple departments and let departments present data at an aggregate level. Department sizes vary (Mazur’s department of two, for example), so larger departments’ responsibilities are split into divisions. Department “parent” scorecards branch into division “child” scorecards, and data rolls up from low levels to high, so all three levels of data interact.

Data interaction at the division level involves day-to-day tasks. From there, divisions come together to see their impact as a department. Mazur notes that offices with solid performance management programs tend to have operational performance measures for divisions and more strategic measures for departments.

“Departments have reported out on how they’ve become successful and integrated performance management and process improvement programs.”

“Align Arapahoe”

Reporting cadences exist at all three levels. Quarterly reports generally happen in meetings among program owners and staff, and larger departments’ meetings include division managers. Departments may also report monthly depending on size or how specific measures are performing. Each month, the county hosts meetings open to the public, called “Align Arapahoe,” that showcase performance measures tied to the overall strategic plan. The county’s external dashboard and county-level report-outs are updated quarterly. The county worked closely with departments in the dashboard’s development and has received positive feedback from internal stakeholders. Mazur was excited to market the dashboard further to the public to gain feedback from external stakeholders as well.

Align Arapahoe: Performance Based Culture at the core of Be Community Focused, Be Fiscally Sustainable and Provide Essential and Mandated Services

Champions

Mazur says 50% of her job is relationship-building, which she puts into practice by identifying “Champions” within county departments. Presenting on success at Align Arapahoe meetings - how the department found it and how they will maintain it - motivates process improvement and buy-in. Mazur finds that the county’s “freeform” reporting approach gets employees more excited to engage with the data that matters to them than being forced to discuss it at set intervals. Participation at the Director level is part of annual performance reviews with the board, which promotes top-down engagement.

One champion’s efforts show in the county’s Utility Use measure, which tracks electricity, natural gas, and water usage. The department is technically on target, but its champions actively try to lower usage to prevent rising costs for the county. In ClearPoint, Mazur opens thriving divisional or departmental scorecards to share exemplary structures with the rest of the organization.

Arapahoe County has improved its reporting practices since implementing ClearPoint. Mazur’s advice for organizations struggling with performance management: celebrate small wins, start small, and find those champions. Build on individuals who will help build on an organizational level.

Special thanks to Laura Mazur for sharing Arapahoe County’s best practices in performance management. Click to view the rest of ClearPoint’s Community Advisory Board!

Additional Case Studies

City of Akron logo

City of Akron, Ohio

The Together for Akron Community Dashboard home page in a browser frame, next to the headline How the City of Akron keeps its strategic plan public, every quarter
City of St. Cloud, Florida logo

City of St. Cloud, Florida

Aerial view of the St. Cloud, Florida, lakefront with a sandy beach, a marina and tree-lined neighborhoods
City of Bartlett, Tennessee logo

City of Bartlett, Tennessee

Adults and children fishing from a lakeshore at sunset in Bartlett, Tennessee