Germantown, Tennessee received the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award in 2019. See how the city plans and tracks progress with ClearPoint Strategy.
- Hand plan development to a steering committee that represents the community. Germantown's 30-member committee spanned age, race, gender and neighborhood, so residents owned Germantown Forward 2030.
- Track the plan by key performance area and publish it on a community dashboard. Citizens saw each area's status and KPIs, supporting the customers criterion.
- Win your state Baldrige program's honor before applying nationally. The Tennessee Center for Performance Excellence's top honor is an unofficial prerequisite for the national award.
- Keep strategy, measures and results in one system before you apply. Germantown exported much of its 55-page application data straight from ClearPoint.
- Read how Fort Collins won the Baldrige award next. It is a second city's route to the same national honor.
Many organizations strive for excellence, whether in one department, for one goal, or as a mandate for the whole workforce. Not every organization lives up to it. The City of Germantown, Tennessee, does. In 2019 it received the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award, an honor few organizations achieve.
ClearPoint Strategy plays a role in Germantown’s journey with its platform for strategic planning, performance tracking, and data management. With ClearPoint, organizations can put the Baldrige criteria into practice in a structured way.
What is The Baldrige Excellence Framework?
The Baldrige Excellence Framework is a globally recognized set of criteria for performance excellence. It helps organizations improve how they perform.
The 7 Elements of the Baldrige framework
It offers a systems approach to managing an organization by integrating the key areas listed below. The framework's criteria, core values, and scoring guidelines help organizations assess their performance and identify strengths and opportunities for improvement. Organizations in many sectors use it to improve customer satisfaction, employee engagement, operational effectiveness, and financial results. The Baldrige award recognizes U.S. organizations that demonstrate unceasing drive for “radical innovation, thoughtful leadership, and administrative improvement.”
The award ties into the ideals of the overarching Baldrige framework:
- Raise awareness about the importance of performance excellence.
- Recognize companies that show performance excellence and pass on this information to other organizations to tailor it for their own needs.
- Motivate companies to improve their quality standards and strive for excellence.
- Help organizations embody the competitive spirit and drive the economy forward.
The Baldrige criteria for performance excellence cover seven assessment areas:
- Leadership
- Strategy
- Customers
- Measurement, analysis, and knowledge management
- Workforce
- Operations
- Results
To win the award, Germantown (and other past winners) had to excel within these categories. Below we share the story of how it went from a recession-recovering city to a strategically driven, award-winning community in less than a decade.
Germantown, TN –A Baldrige Excellence Framework Success Story
Germantown’s journey to Baldrige award winner took the combined effort of city leaders, staff, and citizens, with a little support from ClearPoint Strategy. The inspiration for seeking the award came from Patrick Lawton, Germantown’s City Administrator. Lawton returned from a conference in 2010 with the aftermath of the 2008 recession still on his mind. He wanted his city to pursue Baldrige excellence.
Long-Term Planning
Fast forward to 2015, when the Board of Mayor and Aldermen approved a process for developing Germantown Forward 2030, a long-term strategic plan meant to guide the growth and development of the community for the next 15 years.
To make the strategic planning process a truly grassroots effort, the Board handed over development of the plan to a 30-member steering committee to ensure community ownership. Steering committee members represented all aspects of the community with respect to age, race, gender, and neighborhood.
The year-long planning process was facilitated by city staff to provide support and guidance and ensure completion of the plan. The process aimed to understand and influence the future rather than simply prepare for or adapt to it. It aligned resources to close the gap between present conditions and desired outcomes.

The Germantown Forward 2030 plan captured this ideal by focusing on quality-of-life issues, fiscal responsibility, strong public safety, and community engagement. It would guide Germantown through the economic, environmental, and social conditions in which the city operates.
Tracking Progress
After creating the plan, city leaders tracked progress in nine key performance areas (see image below) using ClearPoint’s strategy execution software. Within ClearPoint, the city aligned the overarching performance areas with its objectives, KPIs, and action plans. It also used the software to track internal metrics.
City leaders also wanted to share their progress with citizens, so they partnered with ClearPoint to create a community dashboard, a public-facing website that people could visit to see the status of key performance areas and the underlying action plans and KPIs that were influencing each area.


Working Its Way To The Top
With Lawton’s Baldrige goal in mind, the city took an early step toward national recognition by working with the Tennessee Center for Performance Excellence, the state-based Baldrige program.
The city’s work on the Germantown Forward 2030 strategic plan and community dashboard helped it win a top honor from the Tennessee Center, an unofficial prerequisite for applying for the national Baldrige award.
Using ClearPoint Strategy Software to See The Baldrige Framework In Action
In 2019, the Germantown team set its sights on the national award. It put together a 55-page award application that covered all seven Baldrige criteria for performance excellence. It was a large effort, but the team already had much of the information and data it needed in ClearPoint and could export it for the application.
Preparing the application showed how ClearPoint supports four of the seven criteria mentioned at the beginning of the post:
- Strategy: By creating the Germantown Forward 2030 strategic plan and tracking it in ClearPoint, the city understood its strategy and how it was carrying out strategic decisions.
- Customers: With the community dashboard, Germantown gave its customers (citizens) a transparent look at its efforts, which helped maintain lasting relationships.
- Measurement, analysis, and knowledge management: ClearPoint let the city track components of key performance areas. The city knew how it was progressing toward its 2030 goals and how best to use resources going forward.
- Results: ClearPoint put all this information in one place, so leaders could create timely reports to share internally and with the community.
A Big Win & Looking Forward
In summer 2019, a team of independent examiners reviewed the city’s application and determined that Germantown was worthy of further review. Out of 26 applicants, only 12 received a site visit.
In October 2019, city staff hosted a team of nine Baldrige examiners for a week-long review of city operations. ClearPoint made it simple to show the required information. The Baldrige team interviewed leaders, reviewed documents, clarified and verified their findings from the initial application, and visited with employees from across the organization.
On November 12, Lawton received a call from Secretary of Commerce Wilbur Ross, who shared the news that the city had reached its 10-year goal and would receive the 2019 Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award. Germantown was one of only four municipalities nationwide to have ever received the honor.
For Lawton, this is only the beginning. Together with other city leaders, he plans to work through the feedback report from the application and address the opportunities for improvement it identified, so the city keeps doing its best for its citizens.
Read how the City of Fort Collins was named a recipient of the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award in our other blog.
Transform Your Strategy Execution with ClearPoint Strategy Software
The Baldrige excellence framework is one of many performance assessments ClearPoint’s strategy execution software can help you excel at. Organizations of all sizes can use ClearPoint to execute strategy, manage projects, save time on reporting, and reach higher levels of excellence. ClearPoint Strategy gives you the tools to drive performance excellence, whether you're a city aiming for national recognition or an organization working on continuous improvement.
Book a personalized demo to get started.
Common questions
What are the key benefits of using the Baldrige Excellence Framework?
The key benefits of using the Baldrige Excellence Framework include:
- Improved Performance: Enhances overall organizational performance by providing a structured approach to performance management.
- Increased Customer Satisfaction: Focuses on understanding and meeting customer needs, leading to higher satisfaction and loyalty.
- Operational Efficiency: Streamlines processes and improves efficiency through continuous improvement practices.
- Strategic Alignment: Aligns organizational activities with strategic goals and objectives.
- Employee Engagement: Encourages employee involvement and engagement through a focus on leadership and workforce development.
- Innovation and Learning: Promotes a culture of innovation and organizational learning, driving long-term success.
How can the Baldrige Excellence Framework be used to improve specific areas of an organization, such as customer satisfaction or operational efficiency?
The Baldrige Excellence Framework can improve specific areas by:
- Customer Satisfaction: Utilizing the customer focus criteria to gather and analyze customer feedback, identify customer needs, and implement improvements based on this data.
- Operational Efficiency: Applying the operations focus criteria to evaluate and enhance key processes, eliminate waste, and streamline operations.
- Leadership: Strengthening leadership practices to create a clear vision and foster a positive organizational culture.
- Workforce Engagement: Developing workforce focus criteria to boost employee satisfaction and productivity through training and development.
- Measurement and Analysis: Using the measurement, analysis, and knowledge management criteria to track performance and make data-driven decisions.
What are some of the challenges of implementing the Baldrige Excellence Framework?
Some challenges of implementing the Baldrige Excellence Framework include:
- Resource Intensity: Requires significant time and resources to conduct comprehensive assessments and implement changes.
- Change Resistance: Potential resistance from employees and management to adopt new practices and processes.
- Complexity: The framework’s comprehensive nature can be overwhelming, especially for organizations new to structured performance management.
- Sustaining Momentum: Maintaining continuous improvement efforts over the long term can be challenging.
- Customization Needs: Adapting the framework to fit the specific context and needs of the organization may require significant effort.
How can organizations get started with using the Baldrige Excellence Framework?
Organizations can get started with the Baldrige Excellence Framework by:
- Familiarizing with the Framework: Understanding the criteria and structure of the Baldrige Excellence Framework.
- Conducting a Self-Assessment: Performing an initial self-assessment to identify strengths and areas for improvement.
- Engaging Leadership: Securing commitment and support from top leadership.
- Developing an Action Plan: Creating a detailed action plan to address identified gaps and implement improvements.
- Training and Development: Providing training for employees to understand and apply the framework’s principles.
- Monitoring and Evaluation: Continuously monitoring progress and evaluating results to ensure ongoing improvement.
What are some real-world examples of organizations that have successfully implemented the Baldrige Excellence Framework?
Real-world examples of organizations that have successfully implemented the Baldrige Excellence Framework include:
- Pewaukee School District: Improved student performance and community engagement through comprehensive application of the framework.
- Lockheed Martin Missiles and Fire Control: Enhanced product quality and operational efficiency, leading to significant business growth.
- Sutter Davis Hospital: Achieved high levels of patient satisfaction and operational excellence.
- MidwayUSA: A small business that used the framework to improve customer satisfaction and business performance.
- Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company: Applied the framework to maintain exceptional service quality and customer satisfaction, leading to multiple Baldrige Awards.








%2520Strategy%2520vs%2520Tactics%2520Differences%252C%2520Examples%2520%2526%2520How%2520to%2520Track%2520Both.jpg)




















.png)




.png)


















.webp)














%2520OKRs%2520vs%2520KPIs%2520Breaking%2520Down%2520the%2520Difference.jpg)