You’ve set your objectives—but you need to be able to evaluate them with measures.
Key Takeaways
  • Choose measures your employees can influence through normal work or projects. A measure no one can move gives no one a reason to act.
  • Make each result readable in under a second. Anyone should grasp performance that fast and the analysis in under 10 seconds, so use easy-to-read charts.
  • Give every Customer and Financial objective at least one outcome measure. Assign driver, or leading, measures mainly to the Internal and Learning & Growth perspectives.
  • Cap the scorecard at 25 measures, 1-2 per objective. More than that produces conflicting performances and hides how you're doing.
  • Set targets with How To Set KPI Targets. Start with a stretch target, then back into annual and quarterly targets.
Google AI answers

Get our answers first in Google.

Add ClearPoint as a preferred source →

You’ve created and written out your strategic objectives—which is a great first step. But now you need to know how to measure the success of your strategic plan, and measures are the best indicator of your performance. Think of your strategy as a plane—without altitude, speed, and directions, the plane is useless! The same is true for measures—which should always help progress your objectives, even if indirectly.

Strategic measures are used to track your progress in achieving your objectives and goals. For example, if your objective is to retain current customers, you’ll ask yourself, “How are we doing toward meeting this particular goal?” The answer to that question is the measure. In this example, it may be your customer renewal percentage going up or down.

The City of Dublin, Ohio, started from the same kind of question. Before ClearPoint, departments reported through their own PowerPoint presentations, which led to unclear reporting and different readings of the same data. The City Manager began asking, “How are we winning?” That forced the team to decide which measures to track. Brandon Brown, Director of Performance Analytics, tested each candidate measure by asking, “How does it change your Tuesday?” If the answer is that it changes nothing, the measure probably isn’t strategic.

With this in mind, here are some helpful tips you can put into practice for selecting the right strategic measures.

How To Select The Right Strategic Measures: A Few Things To Keep In Mind

The Qualities Of A Good Strategic Measure

  • Quantifiable: Making sure your measures are objective (based on statistical fact) and not subjective (based on instinct or “gut feel”) is critical.
  • Understandable: It should take someone in the organization less than a second to understand how you’ve performed on a measure and less than 10 seconds to understand the analysis or recommendations. Easy-to-read charts and graphs that can be quickly consumed are key for this.
  • Actionable: You don’t want to choose measures you can’t impact. It’s important that your employees feel they can influence the measure through normal work or specific projects you put in place.
  • Repeatable: You don’t want the measure to be useful only once. You should be able to track progress on the measure over time so you can analyze critical trends. If you look at a slightly different measure each month, you will not be able to chart it.
  • Timely: At the very least, strategic measures should be looked at annually, and at the most, monthly. Any time frame longer than that makes it difficult to tie the measure in with your strategic plan.

Check what a measure hides, too. The Washington State Department of Licensing (WDOL) serves six million residents. It found that an average can look fine while some customers have a bad experience. If most people wait about 10 minutes for service, the average wait looks good, but it says nothing about the person who waited two hours. WDOL moved away from averages. Its measures looked at the percentage and raw number of customers who did not get the result they wanted, and its surveys added qualitative questions.

The Difference Between Outcomes & Drivers

  • Outcomes are results-oriented measures. It is difficult to have an impact on these measures directly, but they should give you a clear indication of whether the objective (or strategy) is being achieved.
  • Drivers are input-oriented measures. Progress against these measures should have an impact on the outcome measures. Sometimes people refer to these as leading indicators. Drivers measure the activities that are taking place that should influence the outcome measures.

Guidelines To Follow When Choosing Your Measures

  1. Be sure to have at least one outcome measure for each strategic objective in the “Customer” and “Financial” perspectives.
  2. Remember that driver measures are assigned primarily to the “Internal” and “Learning & Growth” perspectives.
  3. If more than one measure is applicable, use the measure that best communicates the meaning of the objective.
  4. Don’t create more than 25 measures (or 1-2 measures per objective). Any more than that makes it difficult to figure out how you’re doing, because measures may have conflicting performances.

The limit on the number of measures matters more than it seems. Measure sets tend to grow. WDOL built its Results Management System by 2009, and by 2017 it included over 150 measures and was becoming too overwhelming to be effective. When WDOL relaunched its strategy in early 2019, the team kept the measures most critical to its mission. It then tracked only the measures that were valuable to the agency and its customers. When it developed a measure, it still asked, “Who is my customer and what do they need?”

Case Example: Teach For America

About 10 years ago, Teach For America created a Balanced Scorecard. This case example represents their strategic measures at the time and how they tie to each of their objectives. Note that some of the measures and objectives have been simplified. (You can view an example of their Balanced Scorecard in this article.)

__wf_reserved_inherit

Information To Include In Your Measure Template

The best way to capture your measure information is by having and using a measure template. The chart below represents a simple template that can be used by filling in the answers on the right hand side. Measure templates are valuable because they help you to realize the strength of your measure and help you communicate your thinking behind the three to five word measure name.

Writing measures well takes practice. When Dublin rolled out ClearPoint, teaching departments to write concise, effective measures was one of the first hurdles. Dublin coached department leaders and analysts, and it started by building performance measures and linking them to strategic goals.

Match the template to where you are. Our standard, mid-level and advanced KPI templates start simple: a measure description, an owner, a formula, and a target and actual. Once you have more historical data, add context fields and a tolerance range for each KPI. Larger organizations may also name a data gatherer separate from the measure owner, who is in charge of the measure and its analysis.

__wf_reserved_inherit

The Next Step: Setting Your Measure Targets

Key performance indicators (KPIs) or measure targets are used to communicate the level of performance you’re trying to achieve. There are three critical steps in setting these targets:

  1. Set your long-term or “stretch” target.
  2. Determine your leading and lagging indicators, and make sure the two are linked together.
  3. Define how you back into your annual and quarterly targets based on your long-term target.

These steps are broken down in-depth in our article How To Set KPI Targets.

Common questions

Angel Oh
Angel Oh
Product Manager II & Former Synchronized Swimmer

Angel works alongside the product team to help build new features and improve customer experience.